10. The Odd Life Of Timothy Green
Yes, it's Disney. Yes, it means well. Yes, it has an amiable cast but...it's just far too cutesy for its own good.
The Odd Life Of Timothy Green is the tale of a young couple (played by Joel Edgerton and Jennifer Garner) who find they can't have a child, so they decide to bury a series of notes in the garden of the qualaties their "dream child" would have. Lo and behold, a son (CJ Adams) arrives with leaves on his legs...yes, leaves on his legs.
Whilst I often have particular distain for films which teach a bad moral lesson, I will grant that The Odd Life Of Timothy Green has the opposite problem. It means well, but is very clumsy. It's a slobbering and poorly-trained puppy dog of a movie that will arouse chuckles of incredulity rather than sighs of annoyance. The plot is, for all that it's unique, rather goofy. The actions and motivations of the characters are often very strange, the characters are arch stereotypes and the film has an interesting take on the use of plants (including a pencil made of leaves). The role of Timothy is also badly written, with a small boy with dialogue like you would hear from a thirty-year-old man.
It's harmless and good-natured, but you should only approach it if you have an incredibly high tolerance of schmaltz.
9. 47 Ronin
Sometimes I feel people are a little rough on Hollywood. They treat jt as a factory for producing nothing more than artless syrupy garbage devoid of artistic integrity, overlooking the staggering amount of classics that have poured out of major Hollywood studios as long as that iconic sign's been resting in the Hollywood hills. The worst thing about 47 Ronin, a Universal picture, is that it can be used as an example for all the nay-sayers and cynics.
The film is an "adaptation" of an important Japanese folk tale, extracted to include a white (well, half-white but played by Keanu Reeves) hero, a romantic sub-plot and fantasy creatures that had zero place in the original story and are blatant attempts at jamming marketable ideas into a story that is treated with little of the reverence it deserves.
The film looks interesting and employs a cast of Japanese actors that have some stature in the west (Tadanobu Asano, Kou Shibasaki, Rinko Kikuchi) whilst also playing true to some aspects of Japanese culture, but the film's fallacies with history and culture are all the noticeable whilst Keanu Reeves (an actor who has done better than his wooden reputation might suggest) really feels out of place and not on his a-game. The film foolishly got an earlier release in Japan where it was met with scorn and you don't have ti be Japanese to see where they found the problems.
8. Beautiful Creatures
It seems that you can't move without bumping into film adaptations of teen novels these days. Occasionally some of these, like the Hunger Games adaptations, are actually pretty good. But for every Hunger Games there's usually one or two films like Beautiful Creatures.
Ethan Wate (Alden Ehrenreich) meets the literal girl of his dreams in Lena Duchannes (Alice Englert) but Lena's grandfather is the decidedly odd Macon Ravenwood (Jeremy Irons) a pariah in the town whose people think he's a devil-worshipper. He's not, but he's part of a family of witches and when Lena turns sixteen she will be made into either a good or bad witch and a battle over the future of Lena, and the town of Gatlin, plays out.
The film has obvious Twilighty overtones that push it rather firmly towards that same cloying melodrama that represents the worst associated aspects of such fiction. In a world of good and evil, the film deals in simplistic characterisations, especially within the town of Gatlin, that is portrayed with he most derogatory stereotypes of conservative small-town mentality. A depiction that, give the film's supposed stance on not jumping to negative conclusions on people, cones off as hypocritical.
Emma Thompson and Jeremy Irons may seem as promising casting but the simplistic and over-emotional nature of the story means that their performances are thrown directly into hamminess that can be amusing, along with the tacky dialogue, but this film offers little serious reward.
7. Justin And The Knights Of Valour
Justin (Freddie Highmore) wants to be a brave and courageous knight despite the wishes of his father (Alfred Molina). Teaming up with a feisty girl (Saoirse Ronan) and a batty wizard (David Walliams) Justin must drive out a spurned knight, Heraclio (Mark Strong), and save the day.
On the one hand, Justin And The Knights Of Valour had some things going for it. Few other films of 2013 can compete in terms of sheer star power and sword and sorcery epics, in the right hands, can be brilliant. Justin And The Knights Of Valour is, however, derivative and aesthetically rather ugly with a cast that sound like they're rather be dong anything else (or were perhaps doing something like the housework whilst absent-mindedly thumbing through the script).
In the aftermath of the Shrek series (of whom actor Antonio Banderas produced this Spanish film) there has been a glut of animated fantasy films, such of which like How To Train Your Dragon (2010) have earned critical acclaim, Justin And The Knights Of Valour was, however, a stumble in the wrong direction.
6. Olympus Has Fallen
One of the most notable movie rivalries of this past year was between White House Down and Olympus Has Fallen; two films that take the same premise of a member of White House security having to take on terrorists, following an attack on the building. Ultimately, Olympus Has Fallen won out at the box office whilst White House Down did poorly in the US (though it did gain more popularity in the wider world) but between the two, Olympus Has Fallen is a distinctly inferior effort.
The film's effects leave a little to be desired and the plot is nothing new, but the main issue is how the enemy is portrayed. Putting to one side that there's no way a North Korean terrorist organisation has weapons technology ahead of the US, the film's hawkish attitude towards North Korea and terrorism puts me in mind of the most disturbing pro-war views and ravings as well as providing some rather uncomfortable moments, like suicide bombers and the fact that almost all the East Asian cast (save for those playing the necessary South Koreans) play the enemy.
More could've been done with the situation in the bunker under the White House (especially when you consider you have Morgan Freeman, everyone's favourite actor playing a fictional president...and god) whilst Gerard Butler rampages about, shooting at the baddies. White House Down, for all its follies, was a silly action romp that could laugh at itself and its plot (such as the infamous line, "The President has rocket launcher) it's the dead-pan and rather unnerving way in which Olympus Has Fallen unfolds that has provided its own downfall.
5. The Mortal Instruments: City Of Bones
With a poor taking at the box office, The Mortal Instruments: City Of Bones has fallen at the first hurdle and the seeming promise of more grows ever-distant. Yet another film in the long stream of teen fantasy film adaptations, City Of Bones follows young Clary (Lily Collins) as she discovers that she can see a whole secret world half-angel Shadowhunters are locked in a world of demons and Clary also discovers that she is a shadow hunter.
Much has been made of how generic The Moral Instruments is leaning heavily on the likes of Twilight and Harry Potter but whilst the film's darker elements could've been explored towards a more original end, we instead get a film that is both forgettable and lacking in originality. The character of Jace in particular almost seems like a caricature of a male love interest for the genre, wide-eyed, pale and just a little too scary whilst the romantic sub-plot goes for originality and is then just tossed aside.
With more panache and originality, The Mortal Instruments could've been impressive. As it is, it sadly fell apart before it even began.
4. Playing For Keeps
Another showing on this list for Gerard Butler is this rom-com that flew a little under the radar. Butler plays a retired Scottish footballer living in the US, now looking to pursue a career in broadcasting as well as coaching a youth team that son plays in. He draws the attention of three separate potential love interests (Catherine Zeta-Jones, Judy Greer and Uma Thurman) but he seems particularly stuck on his ex-wife, played by Jessica Biel.
Playing For Keeps has a number of major problems with its rather limp execution and the saccharine tone that affects the very worst romantic comedies. The script is pretty poor and the plot is excruciatingly flawed. Whilst Zeta-Jones, Greer and Thurman (all three are fine actresses whose presence here is a little sad) make for some divergence from the plot, it's incredibly predictable how things work out and despite the romantic angle between Butler and Biel, there's actually little justification for it other than the child.
The new man in Biel's life (undeveloped as he is) seems rather decent and really comes off as a victim of the romantic plot. Above all else, the schmaltzy way it's presented...the over-simplified way it deals with its characters...the lack of any significant insight... Playing For Keeps has one moral that is flawed. The idea is that a couple that has a child is always better off staying together. Sometimes, it's just for the best that they are not. Biel and Butler are such an example.
3. Texas Chainsaw 3D
In 1974, Tobe Hooper's low-budget pseudo-slasher, Texas Chainsaw Massacre was unleashed onto an astounded audience, and provided the world with one of the most intense, visceral and terrifying movies ever made. Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 followed in 1986 and, whilst gaining a following as a cult film all its own, the lighter and more comic tone has divided fans. Since then the series has gone onto lumber around, much like the iconic Leatherface, to poor response.
Texas Chainsaw 3D was probably never expected to be a darling with critics and these low expectations are justified. The film largely takes its cue from the original classic, only set eighteen years on with the baby survivor of a mass shootout on Leatherface's cannibal family now fully grown...and in a contemporary environment despite mathematically the character's age would place us somewhere in the early-90's. Alas, thinking is not the film's strongpoint and the film indulges in the basest problems that the horror genre is often labelled with.
An over-emphasis on gore (ironic, given the original Texas Chainsaw is such a strongly impacting horror film, even while it's almost entirely bloodless) and a tiresome 3D gimmick are on display, the cast are an unmemorable procession of slasher stereotypes (including the rather talented Tania Raymode, here reduced to mere eye candy) and, whilst the film does try and veer towards a sense of camp, it doesn't even pull that off very well. Generally, it's best to just stick with the brilliant initial instalment in the TCM franchise, of which there is an entire sequence that's pasted onto the start of this film.
2. The Host
Poor Saoirse Ronan. One of the most talented young actresses out there and she's here on this list twice. Of her four films in these last twelve months, Byzantium was an interesting vampiric drama, How I Live Now was an acceptable war thriller, Justin And The Knights of Valour, for all its problems at least had Ronan in the most interesting role. The Hoshi is just a fundamental failing in film-making.
Adapted from a book Stephenie Meyer (of Twilight fame), The Host follows a young girl (played by Saoirse Ronan) is only partially infiltrated by an alien intelligence that's part of an international invasion as the girl tries to evade capture. Any sci-fi fan worth their salt will probably pick up on the similarities with Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1956) from the start, but whilst Body Snatchers had a sinister and mysterious undertone, The Host plays its premise gleefully discarding of all understatement.
Key to this is the lack of regard to the principal of "show not tell", a vital strength of film as a story-telling medium. A concept like The Host's admittedly wouldn't work if it was all played in suggestion with no explicit interaction between Ronan and her host invader but every interaction is spoon-fed to the audience with no regards to ambiguity or nuance. The Host is ultimately a film of what you see is what you get and, even with the sci-fi trappings, it's the same generic teen drama (complete with awkward romance) that we've seen so many times before...only this time with an incessant voiceover and a tedious chase plot.
1. A Haunted House
When done well, the fusion of horror and comedy can work very well. This year, You're Next was given a release after two years in distribution limbo and provided ample laughter with screams. You're Next is how to do a horror-comedy
A Haunted House is how NOT to do a horror-comedy.
The film plays much closer to comedy, as an intended spoof of the Paranormal Activity franchise, but it is comedy at its absolute lowest ebb. Damon Wayans and Essence Atkins play a couple moving into a new home, but it quickly becomes clear that they're not the only ones calling the place home. From there, the plot spirals off into "hilarity".
Humour is subjective and different things make different people laugh. Jokes about bodily functions and getting high? It's not my thing but it has its place. But when this film also plays off attacking and, in another scene, raping a woman and plays it off as just part of the comedy, there's a problem. Mixed in with one of the most offensively outdated depictions of a gay man that you will find and parodies that have now been worn paper-thin, A Haunted House is not comedy...it is anti-comedy. It is making jokes out of things that in no sense should be funny and as a result earns "pride of place" as my least favourite film of 2013.
The scariest thing? A Haunted House 2 is on the way...