Starring: Kristen Wiig, Darren Criss, Annette Benning
Having lost a job and her boyfriend (Brian Petsos), struggling playwright, Imogene (Wiig) pretends to attempt suicide in order to win her boyfriend back. Only for it to backfire and Imogene is sent to the hospital before being discharged into the custody of her free-spirited mother (Benning) in Atlantic City During her stay she discovers that her historian father (Bob Balaban) isn't dead as she had been told and sets off to New York Coty with her brother Ralph (Christopher Fitzgerald) and her mother's lodger Lee (Criss) to find him.
Girl Most Likely is a film you really want to like. It's got a decent cast, is put together with some sweetness and seems to have something going for it, only for the film to stumble on its many problems. Fundamentally, the film lacks momentum. The opening to the film is within an environment that is very difficult to relate to or understand as an audience and many of the jokes seem to have been tailored entirely from an American perspective that comes at the expense of being relatable universally (ironically the film opens with our main character as a child criticising Wizard Of Oz of being "provincial").
Kristen Wiig is a good actress but she really shines with sparky and energetic roles such as her performance in Despicable Me 2, earlier this year. Here, she plays the lead character, Imogen. A cynical and ambitious know it all who has a heart but her character arc isn't quite enough to redeem her actions at the start of the film; faking/attempting suicide (it's never really clear which she was trying to accomplish) just to win back a boyfriend is not the sort of thing that protagonists in mainstream comedies should do. Christopher Fitzgerald plays Wiig's sweet-natured and possibly autistic (going by how he associates more with animals than people and his narrow but highly knowledgeable level of interests) brother and his sub-plot is perhaps more deserving of a story.
The film picks up in its second half, when the previously elusive energy kicks in, and there's a clear intention for a whip-smart and likeable comedy in there, despite few moments that will illicit anything more than a titter. It shows promise, but just delivers it too late to sustain much interest.
Next time, Aidan Gillen plays an Englishman who goes to Singapore following the death of his brother, which leads him to reconsider his own future in Mister John.